NEWS RELEASE
DATE: September 19, 2007
FOR RELEASE: Immediately
CONTACT: Bruce Carpenter, Executive Director
(315) 339-2097
State River Advocate Asks Spitzer To Lead
West Canada Creek Watershed Efforts
New York Rivers United Says Bad Situation Getting Worse;
Now Is Time For Top Leader’s Involvement
Rome,NY – Rome-based New York Rivers United has asked Governor Eliot Spitzer to become personally involved in the on-going dispute over allocation of the water resources of the West Canada Creek watershed.
“The West Canada Creek Watershed is one of our state’s finest. Much of the system’s allocation of water resources is not based on sound science or current law,” said NYRU executive director Bruce Carpenter. “Instead, it is based on outdated and conflicting laws and rules enacted in the past century. While often-competing demands for water increase daily, there continues to be lack of sound and current information.”
Water levels at Hinckley are now at an all-time low. Sporting groups are alarmed over negative impacts to this world-class fishery resulting from peaking hydropower plant operations, and local residents along the Creek are also concerned about dwindling water flows. The New York State Canal Corporation continues to draw water from the West Canada/Hinckley system even after the primary recreation season has ended.
“Local governments, citizens, sporting groups and others are calling attention to an issue the has been lingering for years, because no one has been willing to assume a leadership role and address the problem in a comprehensive way,” said NYRU’s Carpenter. “The current debate has not rectified the problem. We believe that without leadership from the Governor’s office, this bad situation will only worsen.”
- more -
Carpenter points out that State Assemblymember RoAnn Destito has recently introduced legislation in Albany that would drastically increase the amount of water the Mohawk Valley Water Authority can withdraw from the West Canada/Hinckley system to provide drinking water for MVWA customers.
NYRU wants to develop a program for identifying and addressing direct and cumulative impacts of the various uses of the creek to ensure an appropriate balance between the competing uses of these waters that is protective of all uses and that will restore and protect these important water resources.
Carpenter said, “Leadership is needed to bring all parties to a negotiating table. Someone at the highest level must call for a complete and comprehensive evaluation of all issues. Parties must then use relevant information to draft a new operational plan that brings the system up-to-date, making it compatible with science and law as it now is written. Science and law are the building blocks that must be used.”
In its letter to Gov. Spitzer, New York Rivers United said, “As New York’s leading river conservation advocate, we call upon you, as the elected governor, to assume this responsibility and to bring all the parties together. We urge you to support completion of the necessary studies, so that negotiations can begin and can be productive. We must not continue in the direction we are currently headed.”
NYRU is an award-winning not-for-profit 501(c)(3) membership organization working throughout New York State to improve water quality, river access, recreational opportunities, ecological diversity, scenic attributes and riparian land use.
#
Attachments:
(1) Copy of September 13, 2007, letter from NYRU to Gov. Spitzer
(2) Copy of September 12, 2007, Resolution adopted by Trenton Town Board
Thursday, September 27, 2007
West Canada Creek--Gov Letter
September 13, 2007
Governor Eliot Spitzer
State Capitol
Albany, NY 12224
RE: West Canada Creek Watershed—Water Wars
Dear Governor Spitzer:
Attached to this letter is a Resolution adopted by the Town of Trenton Town Board on Tuesday, Sept. 12, 2007. This resolution is a result of new legislation and court actions that are currently in process. New York Rivers United believes that this will be the first of many similar actions taken by local governments, citizens, sporting groups and others to call attention to an issue the has been lingering for years, because no one has been willing to assume a leadership role and address the problem in a comprehensive way.
The West Canada Creek Watershed is one of our state’s finest. Yet, much of the demand on the system is NOT based on sound science or current law. Instead, it is based on outdated and conflicting laws and rules enacted in the past century. While the competition for this resource grows, there continues to be lack of sound and current information.
New York Rivers United is not against development; we understand the need for drinking water. NYRU believes that good, clean, safe drinking water is essential. The need for energy is also a given. While hydropower is not completely benign, it can be made “green,” mitigating its adverse impacts. NYRU has been involved statewide in actions to accomplish this. The New York State Canal system is no longer primarily a transportation lane. It is a recreation way, which is certainly important.
On the other side of the equation, the West Canada Creek is a world-class trout fishery, widely enjoyed for boating and fishing. Property values continue to increase along its shores, and Hinckley Reservoir has a State Park. Growth in the watershed is dependent on well water, which is tied to levels in the reservoir. Water now being wasted because of the current old transport system is not being addressed, and the fluctuating flows from power plants are adversely affecting the lower creek. West Canada System is not the only source for drinking water and out–of-basin transfers can lead to larger problems.
The issues are not new, nor are they unique to West Canada. The fight for water is ongoing across this country, and because of increasing, often-competing demands for water, there will be more contention over the issue in New York. The resolution of the battle is not new either. Science and law are the building blocks that must be used.
Leadership is needed to bring all parties to a negotiating table! Someone at the highest level must call for a complete and comprehensive evaluation of all issues. Parties must then use relevant information to draft a new operational plan that brings the system up-to-date, making it compatible with science and law as it now is written.
New York Rivers United calls upon you, as the elected governor, to assume this responsibility and to bring all the parties together. We urge you to support completion of the necessary studies, so that negotiations can begin and can be productive. We must not continue in the direction we are currently headed.
NYRU has asked for such action at other levels of government (see attached letter), but it is clear that new direction must come from the top. The West Canada Creek Watershed is at risk!
We thank you for your interest and look forward to your response. Should you have any questions, I can be reached at (315) 339-2097?
Bruce R. Carpenter
Executive Director
New York Rivers United
Governor Eliot Spitzer
State Capitol
Albany, NY 12224
RE: West Canada Creek Watershed—Water Wars
Dear Governor Spitzer:
Attached to this letter is a Resolution adopted by the Town of Trenton Town Board on Tuesday, Sept. 12, 2007. This resolution is a result of new legislation and court actions that are currently in process. New York Rivers United believes that this will be the first of many similar actions taken by local governments, citizens, sporting groups and others to call attention to an issue the has been lingering for years, because no one has been willing to assume a leadership role and address the problem in a comprehensive way.
The West Canada Creek Watershed is one of our state’s finest. Yet, much of the demand on the system is NOT based on sound science or current law. Instead, it is based on outdated and conflicting laws and rules enacted in the past century. While the competition for this resource grows, there continues to be lack of sound and current information.
New York Rivers United is not against development; we understand the need for drinking water. NYRU believes that good, clean, safe drinking water is essential. The need for energy is also a given. While hydropower is not completely benign, it can be made “green,” mitigating its adverse impacts. NYRU has been involved statewide in actions to accomplish this. The New York State Canal system is no longer primarily a transportation lane. It is a recreation way, which is certainly important.
On the other side of the equation, the West Canada Creek is a world-class trout fishery, widely enjoyed for boating and fishing. Property values continue to increase along its shores, and Hinckley Reservoir has a State Park. Growth in the watershed is dependent on well water, which is tied to levels in the reservoir. Water now being wasted because of the current old transport system is not being addressed, and the fluctuating flows from power plants are adversely affecting the lower creek. West Canada System is not the only source for drinking water and out–of-basin transfers can lead to larger problems.
The issues are not new, nor are they unique to West Canada. The fight for water is ongoing across this country, and because of increasing, often-competing demands for water, there will be more contention over the issue in New York. The resolution of the battle is not new either. Science and law are the building blocks that must be used.
Leadership is needed to bring all parties to a negotiating table! Someone at the highest level must call for a complete and comprehensive evaluation of all issues. Parties must then use relevant information to draft a new operational plan that brings the system up-to-date, making it compatible with science and law as it now is written.
New York Rivers United calls upon you, as the elected governor, to assume this responsibility and to bring all the parties together. We urge you to support completion of the necessary studies, so that negotiations can begin and can be productive. We must not continue in the direction we are currently headed.
NYRU has asked for such action at other levels of government (see attached letter), but it is clear that new direction must come from the top. The West Canada Creek Watershed is at risk!
We thank you for your interest and look forward to your response. Should you have any questions, I can be reached at (315) 339-2097?
Bruce R. Carpenter
Executive Director
New York Rivers United
Thursday, August 23, 2007
West Canada Creek--People
Elected state officials to contact:
Governor Eliot Spitzer
State Capitol
Albany, NY 12224
phone: (518) 474-8390
State Assemblymember RoAnn M. Destito
~ 116th Assembly District –
e-mail: destitr@assembly.state.ny.us
~ Albany Office ~
Room 621
Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-5454
~ District Office ~
Room 401
State Office Building
207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
phone: (315) 732-1055
State Senator Joseph A. Griffo
~ 47th Senate District ~
~ Albany Office ~
Room 944 Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-3334
fax: (518) 426-6921
~ District Office ~
207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
phone: (315) 793-9072
fax: (315) 793-0298
State Assemblymember David R. Townsend
~ 115th Assembly District – see map attached
e-mail: townsed@assembly.state.ny.us
~ Albany Office ~
Room 458 Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-5334
~ District Office ~
4767 State Route 233
P.O. Box 597
Westmoreland, NY 13490
phone: (315) 853-7260
Governor Eliot Spitzer
State Capitol
Albany, NY 12224
phone: (518) 474-8390
State Assemblymember RoAnn M. Destito
~ 116th Assembly District –
e-mail: destitr@assembly.state.ny.us
~ Albany Office ~
Room 621
Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-5454
~ District Office ~
Room 401
State Office Building
207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
phone: (315) 732-1055
State Senator Joseph A. Griffo
~ 47th Senate District ~
~ Albany Office ~
Room 944 Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-3334
fax: (518) 426-6921
~ District Office ~
207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
phone: (315) 793-9072
fax: (315) 793-0298
State Assemblymember David R. Townsend
~ 115th Assembly District – see map attached
e-mail: townsed@assembly.state.ny.us
~ Albany Office ~
Room 458 Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY 12248
phone: (518) 455-5334
~ District Office ~
4767 State Route 233
P.O. Box 597
Westmoreland, NY 13490
phone: (315) 853-7260
West Canada Creek--Letter
August xx, 2007
Assemblymember RoAnn M. Destito - 116th AD
Room 621 Room 401
Legislative Office Building State Office Building
Albany, NY 12248 207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
Opposition to A 03381-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
Dear Assemblymember Destito:
I live in XXXXX, and I depend on West Canada Creek’s water for day-to-day living needs and also for recreation. I’m very concerned about the water quality and quantity in the West Canada Creek/Hinckley system, especially in light of all the current debate going on presently. I think the legislation you are proposing will make a bad situation worse.
I oppose the “West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act” and urge you to reconsider your support for the measure. If this bill is passed, it will be harmful to the ecology now and in the long-term.
What is needed is to conduct a thorough scientific study of this entire system. Before any major changes that could adversely affect the entire system are implemented, we must clearly understand all the problems, identify all the system’s users, and evaluate the different scenarios for environmental impacts.
We also need to enforce the regulations already on the books. Those existing regulations mandate that scientific information be collected and reviewed before any action can be taken for increased water withdrawals. This has not been done yet.
Thank you very much for your interst in this issue.
XXXXXXXX
xxxxxxxx
Assemblymember RoAnn M. Destito - 116th AD
Room 621 Room 401
Legislative Office Building State Office Building
Albany, NY 12248 207 Genesee Street
Utica, NY 13501
Opposition to A 03381-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
Dear Assemblymember Destito:
I live in XXXXX, and I depend on West Canada Creek’s water for day-to-day living needs and also for recreation. I’m very concerned about the water quality and quantity in the West Canada Creek/Hinckley system, especially in light of all the current debate going on presently. I think the legislation you are proposing will make a bad situation worse.
I oppose the “West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act” and urge you to reconsider your support for the measure. If this bill is passed, it will be harmful to the ecology now and in the long-term.
What is needed is to conduct a thorough scientific study of this entire system. Before any major changes that could adversely affect the entire system are implemented, we must clearly understand all the problems, identify all the system’s users, and evaluate the different scenarios for environmental impacts.
We also need to enforce the regulations already on the books. Those existing regulations mandate that scientific information be collected and reviewed before any action can be taken for increased water withdrawals. This has not been done yet.
Thank you very much for your interst in this issue.
XXXXXXXX
xxxxxxxx
West Canada Creek --Action
Talking Points
Opposition to
Assembly Bill: A 03381-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
(Destito is sponsor)
Senate Bill: S 4176-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
(Griffo is sponsor)
O I strongly oppose the so-called “West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act” and urge you to reconsider your support for the measure. It is premature and ill-advised. Rather, what is needed at this critical juncture is:
(1) a comprehensive, scientific watershed analysis on the West Canada Creek, and
(2) enforcement of current regulations.
O I do support the legislative initiative presently being developed by Assemblymember Marc Butler to fund a comprehensive, scientific watershed analysis of the West Canada Creek system.
O Beneficial uses for Hinckley Reservoir and the West Canada Creek include trout waters, recreation, including boating and fishing, water supply, and energy supply. The system faces increased pressures. Hydro plants are peaking; there is a demand for more water for development, and all of this has led to increased involvement by affected citizens.
O I think we need to develop a program for identifying and addressing direct and cumulative impacts of the various uses of the creek to ensure an appropriate balance between the competing uses of these waters that is protective of all uses and that will restore and protect these important water resources.
O I have a growing worry regarding adverse impacts to fish and wildlife and recreational uses of West Canada Creek. I am concerned that the uses of water supply and energy supply are degrading the more sensitive uses of fish and wildlife and recreation.
(1) Need for watershed analysis
One major problem is a lack of scientific information. A comprehensive scientific study of West Canada Creek is what is needed. This is essential if all stakeholders are to understand the complex issues involved in flow management. Such a study can only help resolve the impasses that are facing us now.
Before any major changes that could adversely affect the entire system are implemented, we must clearly understand all the problems, identify all the system’s users, and evaluate the different scenarios for environmental impacts.
(2) Need for enforcement of current regulations
Additionally, such a study is required under current law. New York State’s Environmental Quality Review Act mandates that scientific information be collected and reviewed before any action can be taken for increased water withdrawals. This has not been done yet.
Energy and water supply uses are already adversely affecting fish and wildlife and recreational uses on the West Canada Creek system. The state Department of Environmental Conservation has the duty to address the adverse impacts on fish and wildlife and recreational uses. DEC’s legal authorities/responsibilities come from the Clean Water Act, the state’s Environmental Conservation Law, and the state’s Environmental Quality Review Act.
Opposition to
Assembly Bill: A 03381-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
(Destito is sponsor)
Senate Bill: S 4176-A West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act
(Griffo is sponsor)
O I strongly oppose the so-called “West Canada Creek Riparian Rights Act” and urge you to reconsider your support for the measure. It is premature and ill-advised. Rather, what is needed at this critical juncture is:
(1) a comprehensive, scientific watershed analysis on the West Canada Creek, and
(2) enforcement of current regulations.
O I do support the legislative initiative presently being developed by Assemblymember Marc Butler to fund a comprehensive, scientific watershed analysis of the West Canada Creek system.
O Beneficial uses for Hinckley Reservoir and the West Canada Creek include trout waters, recreation, including boating and fishing, water supply, and energy supply. The system faces increased pressures. Hydro plants are peaking; there is a demand for more water for development, and all of this has led to increased involvement by affected citizens.
O I think we need to develop a program for identifying and addressing direct and cumulative impacts of the various uses of the creek to ensure an appropriate balance between the competing uses of these waters that is protective of all uses and that will restore and protect these important water resources.
O I have a growing worry regarding adverse impacts to fish and wildlife and recreational uses of West Canada Creek. I am concerned that the uses of water supply and energy supply are degrading the more sensitive uses of fish and wildlife and recreation.
(1) Need for watershed analysis
One major problem is a lack of scientific information. A comprehensive scientific study of West Canada Creek is what is needed. This is essential if all stakeholders are to understand the complex issues involved in flow management. Such a study can only help resolve the impasses that are facing us now.
Before any major changes that could adversely affect the entire system are implemented, we must clearly understand all the problems, identify all the system’s users, and evaluate the different scenarios for environmental impacts.
(2) Need for enforcement of current regulations
Additionally, such a study is required under current law. New York State’s Environmental Quality Review Act mandates that scientific information be collected and reviewed before any action can be taken for increased water withdrawals. This has not been done yet.
Energy and water supply uses are already adversely affecting fish and wildlife and recreational uses on the West Canada Creek system. The state Department of Environmental Conservation has the duty to address the adverse impacts on fish and wildlife and recreational uses. DEC’s legal authorities/responsibilities come from the Clean Water Act, the state’s Environmental Conservation Law, and the state’s Environmental Quality Review Act.
Friday, April 13, 2007
Notice Of Annual Meeting
NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING
To: Members of New York Rivers United
From: Bruce Carpenter, Executive Director
Date: March 29, 2007
Re: 2007 Annual Meeting
The 2007 annual meeting of New York Rivers United will be held on Saturday, May 19, 2007, at 1:00 p.m. It will be held at the law offices of NYRU Board Chair Ray Bragar:
Bragar Wexler
885 3rd Ave. Suite 3040
New York, NY 10022
The meeting agenda is as follows:
* review of 2006 financial reports
* review of annual report
* election of officers
For information and proxies, send an e-mail to tim_burns@newyorkriversunited.org
To: Members of New York Rivers United
From: Bruce Carpenter, Executive Director
Date: March 29, 2007
Re: 2007 Annual Meeting
The 2007 annual meeting of New York Rivers United will be held on Saturday, May 19, 2007, at 1:00 p.m. It will be held at the law offices of NYRU Board Chair Ray Bragar:
Bragar Wexler
885 3rd Ave. Suite 3040
New York, NY 10022
The meeting agenda is as follows:
* review of 2006 financial reports
* review of annual report
* election of officers
For information and proxies, send an e-mail to tim_burns@newyorkriversunited.org
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)